For CPAs & bookkeepers · November 2026

Year-End Merchant Statement Review: A CPA Checklist

A year-end checklist for CPAs and bookkeepers. Use twelve months of merchant statements to reconcile Form 1099-K, check processing fees, and show your client where the money went.

By Gary Rutledge · Updated · 7 min read

Sooner or later a business client asks it: "Is our card processing bill too high?" It's a fair question to put to the person who already holds the statements. It's also a hard one to answer, because card processing is the one recurring cost with no price list to check it against, and the monthly statement seems written to be filed rather than read.

Year-end is the best time to look. You have twelve months of statements in one place, the annual fees have all landed, and any price increase announced during the year has had time to show up. This checklist covers what to gather, what to reconcile, what to flag and how to book it, so the answer to the client's question is better than a guess.

Key takeaways

  • Use all twelve statements. Annual fees, mid-year price increases and seasonal swings only show up across a full year.
  • Every card payment is on the 1099-K. There is no minimum threshold for payment card transactions, and the form reports gross sales, so it can differ from net deposits.
  • Split the cost before you judge it. Part of the bill is the card networks' cost, which no processor can change. The rest is the processor's price, and that's the part to question.
  • Read the message box. Price changes are announced there, often with a deadline to object, and they usually take effect whether anyone read them or not.
  • Book the fees in more than one line. Network cost, processor charges and any equipment lease each tell the client something different.

What to gather

Reconcile Form 1099-K to merchant statements

A processor that settles card payments reports them to the IRS on Form 1099-K. For payment card transactions there is no minimum reporting threshold. The $20,000 and 200-transaction threshold restored in July 2025 applies to third-party payment networks such as payment apps and marketplaces, not to card processing, according to the IRS's updated Form 1099-K FAQs. Some states set their own, lower thresholds.

The form reports gross card sales: before processing fees, refunds and chargebacks. Net deposits can differ from that total. Start by reconciling the form to gross sales on the monthly merchant statements. The 1099-K breaks the total out by month, which makes a mismatch easy to locate.

Check the name and taxpayer ID on the form while you're there. If they don't match IRS records, the processor can be required to apply backup withholding to the client's card sales, and many processors charge a monthly fee for the mismatch until it's corrected. A line labeled "IRS", "TIN" or "1099" on a statement is worth a question.

If the client changed providers during the year, use the payment processor switching checklist to track both forms and account for changes in settlement timing.

Work out the cost, then split it

The quickest single number is the effective rate: total processing fees for the year divided by total card sales. It's useful for comparing one year with the next. On its own it can't say whether the client is paying too much, because a business that takes many rewards and corporate cards pays more to the card networks than one that takes mostly debit, whoever processes the cards.

So split the fees into two parts:

On interchange-plus pricing, the statement itemizes both, so the split is a matter of sorting lines. On flat-rate or tiered pricing, the network cost is buried inside the rate, and the statement alone often can't separate them. That's worth saying in the conversation: the client can't see what they're paying the processor.

For clients open only part of the year, follow the seasonal merchant statement review: use the full year’s sales and count fixed fees for the months they actually bill. One busy month multiplied by twelve can overstate the cost.

Read the message box on every statement

Processors announce price changes in the notice section of the statement: a new fee, a higher markup, an amended agreement. Most notices carry an effective date, and some give a deadline to object or close the account. Read the notices across all twelve months, then check the statements that follow for the change. An increase announced in March usually shows up by May.

Fees to flag

Use the guide to hidden credit card processing fees to decide which charges to stop, correct, or raise with the processor.

Booking it so the client can see it

Many sets of books carry processing costs as one "merchant fees" line. Splitting it makes next year's review faster and gives the client a number they can act on. A layout that works:

Record sales gross and fees as an expense, rather than booking net deposits as sales. That keeps sales consistent with the 1099-K, and it keeps the cost of processing visible.

Questions for the client to ask the processor

  1. Which pricing model is the account on (interchange-plus, tiered or flat-rate), and what is the markup?
  2. Can you send a current copy of my pricing schedule and every fee on my account?
  3. Which notices of changes did you send this year, and what changed?
  4. Why am I charged a PCI non-compliance fee, and how do I complete the questionnaire?
  5. What are these downgrades, and what would stop them?

Where Statement Forensics fits

Statement Forensics audits processing statements line by line. Visa and Mastercard lines are checked against the networks' complete published rate tables for the statement's date. Debit lines are checked network by network. Every figure is reconciled to the statement's own printed totals. The audit separates the card networks' cost from the processor's price, finds the fees above, reads the notices, and covers up to twelve months in one report.

You get two reports from one audit: a plain-English report for the owner, and a detailed one with every working figure for you. The statements are deleted when the reports are delivered. We don't sell processing or software, have no processor, ISO or platform affiliation, and take no residuals or referral fees, so nobody here is paid more if your client switches than if they stay.

To see it on one client, send a recent statement, with the client's permission, to audit@statementforensics.com, or ask for the sample report first. There's more in the CPA and bookkeeper brief.

See a sample audit report

Frequently asked questions

Why doesn't the client's 1099-K match their deposits?

The 1099-K reports gross card sales, before processing fees, refunds and chargebacks are taken out. Deposits are net of some or all of those. Reconcile the 1099-K to the gross sales on the monthly statements instead.

Is there a threshold before card sales are reported on a 1099-K?

Not for payment card transactions. The $20,000 and 200-transaction threshold applies to third-party payment networks such as payment apps and online marketplaces. Card processors report card sales regardless of amount, and some states set their own reporting thresholds.

What is a good effective rate for card processing?

It depends on the client's card mix, average sale and how cards are accepted, so there is no single good number. Splitting the cost into the card networks' part and the processor's part answers the more useful question: what is the client paying the processor?

How many statements do I need for a useful review?

One recent statement shows the pricing and most of the fees. Twelve months shows annual fees, price increases announced during the year and seasonal patterns, which makes year-end the natural time for a full review.

About the authorGary Rutledge built Statement Forensics after 35 years in banking risk, processing, acquiring and payment facilitator operations. Beech Edwards LLC has no processor, ISO or platform affiliation, takes no residuals or referral fees, and has nothing to sell you after the report.

Find out what you’re really paying to accept cards.

Independent, plain-English statement audits. No processing sold, nothing to switch you to. Statements are deleted on delivery.

Request an audit