When a business client changes card processors, the decision usually happens without the accountant. A sales rep quotes a lower rate, the owner signs, and the first sign of it in the books is a new name on the deposits. But the switch touches everything a CPA or bookkeeper cares about: the cost of processing, the cash cut-off, the 1099-K, and a set of fees from the old account that can keep billing after the client thinks it's closed.
Here is what to check before the client signs, while the old account closes, and on the first statements from the new processor, when the promised price meets the charged one.
Key takeaways
- Get every fee in writing before signing, not only the rate. The rate quoted is rarely the whole price.
- The old account doesn't close itself. Monthly fees, equipment leases and gateway subscriptions can keep billing until each is cancelled as its own agreement requires.
- Check the first three statements from the new processor against the quote, line by line.
- Expect two 1099-Ks for the year of the switch, and possibly a change in how deposits and fees hit the bank account.
- The PCI questionnaire starts over. A new processor usually needs its own, and charges a non-compliance fee until it has it.
Before the client signs
Ask the client to get the new processor's pricing schedule, not a summary. It should list:
- The pricing model and markup: interchange-plus with a stated markup, tiered rates, or a flat rate.
- Every recurring fee: monthly, annual, PCI, statement, gateway, per-transaction and minimum-processing fees.
- The term and renewal: how long the agreement runs, whether it renews automatically, and how to give notice.
- The early termination fee, and whether the agreement charges liquidated damages based on the remaining term.
- Equipment: bought, rented or leased. A lease is usually with a separate leasing company, runs for years, and often can't be cancelled even if the processing account closes.
- Funding: how quickly deposits arrive, whether fees are taken daily or once a month, and whether the processor can hold a reserve.
Then compare like with like. A quote that leaves the network cost in on one side and out on the other isn't a comparison. If the client's current statement shows the card networks' cost separately, the honest comparison is the processor's price against the processor's price.
The checklist for avoiding hidden processing fees gives you a second pass through the quote and equipment agreement.
Closing the old account
A new account opening doesn't close the old one. Until it is closed as the agreement requires, usually in writing and sometimes with a notice period, the old processor can keep billing monthly fees, minimums and PCI non-compliance fees against an account with no sales.
- Read the termination terms before the client gives notice, and set aside any early termination fee.
- Cancel each agreement separately: the processing account, any gateway, and any equipment lease or rental.
- Keep the old account's bank debits open until the final statement arrives. Refunds and chargebacks on old sales still settle through it.
- Watch the bank account for two or three months afterward. A debit from the old processor after closing is a question for the processor, and often a refund.
If the old processor still holds a reserve or payout, check what happens to held funds and reserves before assuming the final deposit settles the account.
The first statements from the new processor
The first statement is the test of the quote. Check it line by line against the pricing schedule:
- Is the markup what was promised? On interchange-plus pricing, the markup should be stated and applied the same way on every line.
- Are there fees the schedule didn't list? Watch for PCI, gateway, "network" and "regulatory" fees that weren't in the quote.
- Is a PCI non-compliance fee billing? Compliance with the old processor doesn't carry over. The client usually needs to complete the new processor's questionnaire.
- Do the network fees match the networks? A line labeled as a card brand fee should match what the brand charges. A difference is markup.
Check the second and third statements too. Introductory pricing can end, and a price increase can be announced in the notices within months of signing. A fee billed annually may first appear months in.
In the books and at tax time
- Two 1099-Ks. Each processor reports the card sales it settled during the year. Together they should match the year's gross card sales.
- Fees may hit the bank differently. One processor may deduct fees from each day's deposit, while another debits them once a month. That changes how deposits reconcile to sales, and which month the fees land in.
- Deposit timing may change. A move from next-day to two-day funding shifts card sales near the year-end into the next year's deposits. It's worth knowing for the cut-off.
- Termination fees and leases. Record an early termination fee as its own item, and keep any continuing lease payments on their own line, so neither is mistaken for the new processor's cost.
At year-end, follow the Form 1099-K reconciliation steps and match each form to the gross sales reported by that processor.
Questions for the client to ask
- Can I have the full pricing schedule, with every fee, before I sign?
- What is the term, does it renew automatically, and what does it cost to leave early?
- Is the equipment bought, rented or leased, and from whom?
- When will deposits arrive, and are fees taken daily or monthly?
- How do I complete your PCI questionnaire, and when does a non-compliance fee start?
Where Statement Forensics fits
Statement Forensics audits processing statements line by line, and a switch is when it helps most. On the client's current statement, it separates the card networks' cost from the processor's price, so the new quote can be compared fairly. On the first statements from the new processor, it checks the price the client was promised against the price they're charged, and finds the fees nobody mentioned.
Visa and Mastercard lines are checked against the networks' complete published rate tables, and every figure is reconciled to the statement's own printed totals. You get a plain-English report for the owner and a detailed one for you. The statements are deleted when the reports are delivered. We don't sell processing or software, have no processor, ISO or platform affiliation, and take no residuals or referral fees.
Send a recent statement, with the client's permission, to audit@statementforensics.com, or ask for the sample report first. There's more in the CPA and bookkeeper brief.
Frequently asked questions
Can the old processor keep charging after the client switches?
Yes, until the account is closed as the agreement requires. Monthly fees, minimums and PCI non-compliance fees can keep billing an account with no sales. Equipment leases and gateways are often separate agreements that each need cancelling.
Will the client get two 1099-K forms?
Usually. Each processor reports the card sales it settled during the year. Together they should add up to the year's gross card sales.
What is the most common surprise after a switch?
Fees that weren't in the quote, often a PCI non-compliance fee because the new processor needs its own questionnaire, and old-account fees that keep billing because the account was never formally closed.
How soon after a switch should the statements be checked?
On the first statement, and again on the next two. The first shows whether the pricing matches the quote, and the next two catch fees billed less often and early price changes.