Since 2011, federal rules have capped what the biggest banks can charge your business when a customer pays with one of their debit cards. On October 26, 2026, a federal appeals court agreed that the Federal Reserve set that cap the wrong way, and upheld a ruling that throws it out.
That sounds like a big change to your debit fees. For now, it isn't one. The cap is still in force while the case runs its course, and nobody yet knows what will replace it. This guide covers what the court decided, what happens next, what hasn't changed, and what to watch for on your processing statement.
This is general information, not legal or financial advice.
Key takeaways
- The cap on debit cards from banks with $10 billion or more in assets is 21 cents plus 0.05% of the sale, plus 1 cent for banks that meet fraud-prevention standards.
- On October 26, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit unanimously upheld a 2025 ruling that the Fed's cap breaks the law that created it, because the Fed counted costs Congress told it to leave out.
- Nothing has changed at the register yet. The cap stays in force until the ruling formally takes effect, and further appeals could delay that.
- The court didn't set a new cap. It sent the rule back to the Fed. A second appeals court is considering the same rule, and a split between the two could take the question to the Supreme Court.
- Debit cards from smaller banks, and the rules that let your processor route debit over a lower-cost network, aren't affected.
What the cap is
When a customer pays with a debit card, most of what your business pays goes to the bank that issued the card. That's interchange. In 2010 the Durbin Amendment told the Federal Reserve to make debit interchange "reasonable and proportional" to the issuing bank's cost of handling the transaction. The Fed's rule, Regulation II, has capped it since October 2011:
- 21 cents per transaction,
- plus 0.05% of the sale,
- plus 1 cent for banks that meet the Fed's fraud-prevention standards.
On a $40 sale, that's at most 24 cents. The cap applies only to cards from banks with $10 billion or more in assets. On a statement, these debit lines are usually marked "REG" or "regulated". Debit cards from smaller banks and credit unions are exempt, and each card network sets their rates.
What the court decided
The case was brought by Corner Post, a North Dakota truck stop and convenience store. Merchant groups had argued for years that the cap was set too high. In August 2025, a federal court in North Dakota agreed that the Fed's method was unlawful and vacated the cap, but put its own ruling on hold while the Fed appealed.
On October 26, 2026, a three-judge panel of the Eighth Circuit unanimously agreed. The law lets the Fed count a bank's incremental cost of a particular transaction. The court read that as the cost of one more transaction, and found the Fed had also counted fixed costs, such as overhead, that Congress told it to exclude. The court said the Fed must at least sort costs into those tied to a transaction and those that aren't.
The court did not set a new cap, and it didn't tell the Fed what the number should be. It sent the rule back to the Fed to redo.
What happens next
- The ruling isn't in effect yet. An appeals court decision takes effect when the court issues its formal mandate. When a federal agency is a party, the losing side has 45 days to ask for a rehearing, and the mandate follows a week after that deadline, or after any rehearing request is denied. Without a rehearing request, one analysis puts that around mid-December 2026. A court could also extend the hold while the case is appealed further.
- A second appeals court is weighing the same rule. In a Kentucky case brought by a pizza restaurant, a federal court upheld Regulation II in September 2025. The Sixth Circuit heard the appeal on October 22, 2026. If it rules the other way from the Eighth Circuit, the Supreme Court becomes more likely to take the question.
- The Fed has to write a new rule. In 2023 it proposed lowering the cap to 14.4 cents plus 0.04%, with a 1.3-cent fraud adjustment. It has never adopted that proposal. Because the proposal used the same cost method the court rejected, legal analysts don't expect it to be enough on its own.
- What applies in between is unclear. Neither court has said what limit, if any, would apply to big-bank debit between the old cap ending and a new rule taking effect. That's the question to watch.
Merchant groups welcomed the decision and expect a lower cap in the end. Bank groups warned that the decision is not the last word.
What hasn't changed
- The cap you're billed under. Big-bank debit still clears at 21 cents plus 0.05%, plus the fraud-prevention cent where it applies.
- Smaller-bank debit. Cards from banks under $10 billion were never capped, and each network still sets their rates.
- Debit routing. The rule that every debit card must work on at least two unaffiliated networks, and that the merchant, through its processor, chooses which one carries the sale, wasn't part of this case.
- Credit cards. The cap applies to debit. The separate proposed Visa and Mastercard settlement covers credit. The court heard arguments on November 16 and did not rule at the hearing.
What to watch on your statement
When the cap changes, the first place it should show is your regulated debit lines. Today a regulated line usually reads at 0.05% plus 22 cents: the 21-cent cap plus the fraud-prevention cent. What happens next depends on how you're priced:
| Your pricing | What a change to the cap would do |
|---|---|
| Interchange-plus (cost-plus, pass-through) | Interchange is passed through at cost, so the new rate should appear on your regulated lines the month it takes effect. Check that it does. |
| Tiered or flat rate | Your rate doesn't move on its own. A lower cap would widen your processor's margin, and a higher one would narrow it, until your pricing changes. Read any notice about debit pricing closely. |
Also check your mix. If a large share of your debit sales are regulated, which is common because the biggest banks issue most debit cards, a change to the cap matters more to you. And keep an eye on routing. A lower-cost network is often available on the same card, and how your processor routes debit can matter as much as the cap itself.
Questions to ask your processor
- Is my debit interchange passed through at cost, line by line?
- If the federal cap changes, when will my statement show it, and will my rate change with it?
- How are my debit sales routed, and is the lowest-cost network used where it's available?
- What share of my debit volume is regulated, and what share is exempt?
Where Statement Forensics fits
Statement Forensics audits processing statements line by line. Every regulated debit line is checked against the federal cap, and Interlink and Maestro lines against Visa's and Mastercard's published PIN debit rates. STAR, Accel, Pulse, NYCE and the other PIN networks are checked against the highest rate each can charge. When the cap changes, the check changes with it, so the first statement after the change shows whether your processor passed it through.
We don't sell processing or software, have no processor, ISO or platform affiliation, and take no residuals or referral fees. Email a recent statement to audit@statementforensics.com. For more on the networks themselves, read our guide to the debit networks on your statement.
Frequently asked questions
Did my debit card fees change after the court ruling?
No. The cap on big-bank debit is still in force until the appeals court's ruling formally takes effect, and further appeals could delay that. Regulated debit still clears at 21 cents plus 0.05%, plus 1 cent for qualifying banks.
Is there a new debit cap?
Not yet. The court sent the rule back to the Federal Reserve without setting a new number. The Fed proposed a lower cap in 2023 but never adopted it, and that proposal used the cost method the court rejected.
Will debit card fees go down?
Merchant groups expect a lower cap once the Fed counts only the costs the law allows. But the timing and the number are unknown, and the ruling could still be reviewed further, possibly by the Supreme Court.
Does the ruling affect cards from small banks and credit unions?
No. Cards from banks with under $10 billion in assets were never capped. Each card network sets their rates.
Does it change how debit sales are routed?
No. The requirement that every debit card work on at least two unaffiliated networks, with the merchant's processor choosing the route, wasn't part of this case.