Independent merchant statement audit

Independent credit card processing statement audits

Evidence, not promises

What are you really paying to accept cards? Statement Forensics reads a processing statement line by line, separates what the card networks charge from what the processor charges, checks report figures against the statement’s printed totals where the statement format and detail allow, and says plainly what is correct, what is fixable and what to ask.

For merchants

See where your processing fees go, what changed, and what to ask your processor.

Request an audit
For agents and ISOs

Analyze a prospect’s statement, price a proposal from your Schedule A, and check the first bill against the quote.

Request a walkthrough
Gary Rutledge Managing Partner, Beech Edwards LLC

Gary built Statement Forensics after 35 years in banking risk, payment processing, acquiring, and payment facilitator operations. Beech Edwards is independent of processors, ISOs, and payment platforms and earns no residuals from your account.

Every statement leaves a print. The audit reads it — and one line is usually worth the whole exam.

How it works

Request a done-for-you audit by sending up to twelve recent statements to audit@statementforensics.com. Beech Edwards reviews the documents and returns the reports under the service’s existing document-handling process.Use the hosted Statement Forensics application with your authorized account. Statement and Schedule A files are processed in the browser while sign-in and the authorized rate pack come from the hosted service.

STEP 1

Send up to twelve statementsSign in and load up to twelve statements

PDF is fine. One month is enough to start. Up to twelve statements from one account can show changes across the selected period, including nonconsecutive months.The files are selected inside the authorized workspace and read locally in your browser. One month opens the door; batches can include up to twelve statements from one account. Gaps between months are identified, not filled with invented data.

STEP 2

We run the independent auditThe audit runs locally against the authorized pack

The report shows how figures reconcile against your statement’s printed totals and keeps mismatches visible. Supported Visa and Mastercard categories are compared with dated schedules only when the statement period, detail, and mapping support the check; other comparisons remain qualified by their evidence.Authentication, entitlement, and your account identity come from Statement Forensics. Statement and Schedule A contents stay in the browser while the audit applies the authorized pack and reports evidence limits.

STEP 3

Two reports come back. Statements are deleted.Export the reports; the source files stay on your device

A plain-English summary for the owner and a full working report for your agent or bookkeeper. Same numbers, two vocabularies. Statements are deleted on delivery – never shared, never sold.A plain-English summary for the owner and a full working report for your prep – same numbers, two vocabularies. Phase 1 has no statement-upload endpoint; the hosted service receives the account and rate-vintage requests, not the merchant statement.


See what comes back

This is an excerpt from the sample audit — a real report worked from a demo merchant, Sunrise Cafe. The findings marked shown in your report are exactly where yours will differ: request the full sample, or send a statement and see your own.


What the audit finds

Findings anchor to your statement’s own printed lines — in dollars, never vague percentages.

Published rates for supported lines

The audit holds Visa’s and Mastercard’s whole US rate tables — every program, every card-product column, from the networks’ own current editions. Every line that matches a published rate is confirmed at it, and every other one is named with the reason it cannot be priced — a program the loaded schedules no longer carry, or an interregional rate no US schedule publishes. Discover publishes no public US schedule, so a Discover line is only ever confirmed at cost, where it matches the Discover schedule the audit holds, and is never called overcharged. American Express publishes no US merchant schedule, so an Amex line is checked against the OptBlue program pricing guide only where the statement names its pricing level; a line that names no level is reported from the statement’s own figures and not priced. No line is left blank and no gap is left unexplained.

Not “you have chargebacks” — which chargebacks

Where the statement prints a reason against each dispute, they are grouped and the fix is named. Fraud is an authentication problem. “Not as described” is a fulfillment problem no gateway setting touches. A chargeback on a declined authorization is your own process and is close to indefensible. Most merchants have been sold fraud tools for what turns out to be a shipping problem.

A brand can be a quarter of your month and cost your processor nothing

Some statements pass a whole card brand straight through: the brand bills you directly and your processor only moves the traffic, so the line prints a rate of zero for a cost of zero. On one statement that was 28% of everything the business ran that month; leave it out and a $271,968 month reads as a $194,396 one. The audit states the volume, the count, the share, and which volume your effective rate is actually measured on — then names the two documents that hold the rate this statement cannot show.

Every dollar sorted — and checked

Fixed network cost on one side, your processor’s negotiable price on the other — and every network rate compared to the official published schedule in force for that month. Anything charged above it is named, with the dollars to recover.

Money a negotiation can’t reach

Interchange is the card networks’ cost and no processor’s to mark up. Where a line presented as pass-through is billed above the published rate, that difference is named with the dollars behind it. Markup is a different thing and is never added to it — what a processor charges for its service is legitimate, negotiable, and reported so it can be negotiated rather than presented as a finding. Keeping the two apart is what lets the document survive a conversation with the processor.

Price increases — announced in one statement, proved in the next

Processors pre-announce repricing in the statement message text — the paragraph nobody reads. The audit reads it on any statement, whatever the processor’s wording, quotes it exactly, and flags the window to object, which opens whether or not anyone read it. Then, given the following month, it measures what actually changed and links it back: “this increase was pre-announced in the statement messages of the prior statement — flagged before it landed.” On a three-statement set it caught the notice, then proved the increase landed to the basis point — and priced it per month and per year.

Fraud, fines, and monitoring — caught early

Card-testing attacks billed per attempt, network “integrity” fines for faulty authorizations, and dispute levels that lead to monitoring programs — flagged with a one-page brief your agent can act on.

Charges that shouldn’t be there at all

Some fees aren’t negotiable — they’re avoidable. A “PCI non-compliance” charge, for example, disappears entirely once a yearly compliance form is completed. The report says so, in those words.

Promise made, promises kept

Load the new account’s first statement, enter the quoted terms, and get a verdict — green “promise kept” within tolerance, or the overcharge in dollars, with wrong-markup and wrong-model checks.

Your category code, checked

The card programs a statement bills show what kind of business the account is set up as. When they don’t match the business, the audit says so: the wrong code can mean the wrong rates, or cheaper programs the business qualifies for and never gets.

Mastercard’s new ID rule

Since October 23, 2026, Mastercard expects a Transaction Link ID on every recurring and card-on-file charge, and it bills non-compliance from January 31, 2027. When a statement bills that charge, the audit names it and says the fix is in the billing software or gateway. When it shows saved-card Mastercard sales, the questions include whether the ID is being sent.

Hemp, vape and kratom rules, on their own page

Where a statement shows the rules apply — a tobacco, convenience, fuel or liquor category, a smoke or vape shop name, or a processor notice — the report closes with a separate page on the new rules and what to do. It is not a finding, and it never says the business sells these products.

Changes to your account’s fine print

When the bank behind your account changes, or your terms are quietly updated, the audit calls it out and tells you what to verify — before “continued use constitutes acceptance” works against you.

Debit, checked network by network

Nearly three in ten U.S. debit sales run on a PIN network — STAR, NYCE, Pulse, Accel and others — instead of Visa or Mastercard. Each network sets its own price, and most don’t publish it for merchants. That is usually where a statement review stops. This one keeps going.

Every PIN debit line, checked

Interlink and Maestro lines are checked against Visa’s and Mastercard’s published PIN rates. STAR, Accel, Pulse, NYCE, SHAZAM, Jeanie, AFFN and Culiance lines are checked against the highest rate each network can charge for the program the line names. A regulated line, on a big-bank card, is checked against the federal cap. And the processor’s markup on those sales is shown, wherever the statement lets it be measured.

Switch fees, too

Every PIN network charges a small per-transaction switch fee on top. Where the statement itemizes it, the audit compares it with the highest switch fee that network charges, and raises anything above it as a question, with its amount.

Premium tiers, named

Labels like CHOICE, SEL, LTD and PREM mark network tiers that cost more. The report names them and asks the questions that go with them: which networks the debit sales are routed to, who chooses, and whether a lower-cost network is available.

A network’s highest rate is a ceiling, not the cost: a line at or below it checks out, and the report never treats the ceiling as what a line cost. Read the guide to the debit networks on your statement →


Latest from the blog

Plain-English guides to card processing, for owners and for the people who advise them.

View all articles →


Send up to twelve statements, get one report about all of them

Not three reports stapled together, and not one report quietly describing whichever month happened to be on screen. Load up to twelve, consecutive or not, and every finding in the document is the period’s number — the spread above the network floor, the padded-line count, volume by card brand, the cost stack, the returns and disputes screen, and the sentence on the cover.

Findings accumulate

A figure printed under a period heading is the period’s figure. The headline totals are the sum of each statement’s own printed totals — never a merged dataset, because a statement’s total is a fact and a merge of them is not.

Every statement keeps its own page

Per-statement detail lives in an appendix at the back, each section badged with the statement it belongs to. Nothing there is a share of anything, and nothing is lost to the summing.

Ratios are re-tested, not averaged

Returns and dispute rates are computed on the summed sales, credits and chargebacks. A merchant can sit under threshold on a quiet month and over it across the quarter — and the quarter is what an acquirer measures.

A price increase leads page one

If the processor raised the price across the months you sent, it is on the cover with what it costs — and whether it was pre-announced in the statement messages or simply appeared in the pricing. It is never buried on an inside page.

The 2027 dispute rules, visible in 2026

Mastercard’s Global Merchant Audit Program takes effect in 2027 and tightens its chargeback threshold again in 2029, 2030 and 2031. It is scored per location rather than across a whole account, and it counts fraud reported without a chargeback — activity a statement never shows.

A warning with years on it

Where a merchant is comfortably compliant today but would sit inside a later stage, the report says so and names the year. That is time to act, which is the only thing a threshold notice never gives anyone.

The acquirer side, for agents

The program measures acquirers too, with their own tiers and assessments. Portfolio pressure reaches merchants long before a merchant-level threshold does — so it is carried, clearly marked as not a merchant finding.

Sourced out loud

This schedule came from an industry summary rather than Mastercard’s own published document, and the report prints that beside the finding. One figure in it falls where every other ladder rises; it is carried exactly as supplied and flagged, because quietly correcting a source is how a tool starts inventing.

Promise Kept

Was the deal you were sold the deal you got?

Anyone can quote a rate. The first statement on the new pricing is the only place a promise is either kept or it isn’t — and by the time a merchant works that out themselves, it is not a service conversation any more.

A rate you were quoted and a rate you were boarded at are two different things. The first statement after a switch is where the difference shows up, and almost nobody checks it.

Repriced at the terms quoted

That statement’s own card mix is repriced at the promised terms, with interchange and assessments passed through at the published schedules. Expected against actually charged — arithmetic, not opinion.

Three answers, and the cause

Promise kept within tolerance; charged above the quote, in dollars a month and a year; or below, which usually means something was mis-boarded and will be corrected later. Where the cause is visible — the wrong disclosed markup, or bundled pricing where interchange-plus was sold — it is named.

The whole statement, not just the quote

It runs inside a complete audit, so it also reports what else was found: downgrades, chargeback fees, negotiable third-party lines, monitoring exposure. A kept promise and a clean statement are two different findings.

One page you can hand over

It exports on its own, headed with the merchant’s name, the statement period and your details. Your cost basis, margin and split are never on it — by the same rule that governs the full report.

When the statement won’t say what interchange cost

Some statements never name their interchange programs. They bill your card volume under the processor’s own tier labels — and one of those labels can contain dozens of published programs at rates hundreds of basis points apart. This is where most audits quietly guess.

This one refuses. No published rate corresponds to a bucket like that, so no network floor is stated and no spread over it is claimed. The reason matters: a floor calculated anyway collapses to the assessment rate alone — roughly a tenth of a percent, which is the arithmetic of saying interchange cost the processor nothing. Every dollar of your interchange then reads as processor margin, and the claim falls apart at the first question from an acquirer.

Refusing is honest, but on its own it answers nothing. So the audit bounds what it cannot measure, and tells you which part is which.

Known exactly

The fees that contain no interchange at all

Chargeback, compliance, statement, regulatory, address-verification and per-item charges. These are read straight off your page — not estimated, not a range. Every dollar of them is processor-side or brand pass-through, and you can point at the lines.

Bounded, not guessed

The bundled discount

It carries interchange and margin with no line separating them. It is split by card brand and product, and each bucket is priced between the cheapest and the most expensive published program it could have carried — each bound named, and cited to the schedule and effective date it came from.

The two parts add up to the fee total your statement prints on its own face, so nothing falls between them and nothing is counted twice. What comes out is a sentence like “total processor-side cost is between X and Y a month” — quoted as a range because that is what the document supports.

A range is not a hedge. A single figure here would be invented, and inventing one is how an audit gets taken apart in front of the processor. The report also says exactly what would close the range to a number: a statement that names its interchange categories, or a portal export of the detail behind those tier buckets — both of which your processor can produce in a few minutes.

Debit and credit are never bucketed together, because debit spans regulated to unregulated and credit does not. Where a published rate carries a per-item amount as well as a percentage, the per-item side is applied using the transaction counts your statement prints — leaving it out would quietly widen the margin figure in the direction that flatters the finding, and that is not the direction an honest audit errs in.

It has to be able to read your statement first

Processors do not share a format. Every one prints its own categories, its own subtotals and its own idea of what a fee is called — which is why a generic parser produces a confident report full of quiet holes. Each format here has been read from a real statement and is held in place by its own regression test, so it cannot silently stop working.

Interchange-plus & pass-through

Supported interchange categories are compared line by line with the applicable schedule. Unmatched categories remain named and unpriced.

Bundled tiered

Qualified, mid-qualified and non-qualified buckets. The interchange detail is not printed, so no padding is claimed — the cost is bounded instead.

Blended tier with surcharging

One rate per brand, surcharge collected separately, and a discount base that quietly includes refunded volume.

Plan-code statements

Where a bundled discount and an itemized interchange section are both charged — quoting the fee total alone understates the merchant badly.

ERR and billback

Rates derived rather than printed, with the processor’s margin built into the interchange line itself. Reported as markup, never as an overcharge.

Flat-rate

No interchange detail exists to check, so the effective rate and the fee lines are verified instead of pretending detail is there.

Brand-rollup formats

Statements that print only a total per card brand. Pass-through is taken as billed and every total reconciles to the statement’s own summary block.

Scanned and photographed statements

Read twice at full resolution, and the recovered text must reconcile to the statement’s own printed total — or the report says the detail is incomplete rather than showing you a short number.

And a format it has not seen yet is a format that gets added. Send the statement it could not read. It is turned into a permanent regression test at the same time as it is made to work, which is why the list only ever grows — and why nothing already on it quietly breaks when something new arrives.


Released application and evidence scope

Statement Forensics is released. What it compares, what it does not, and how a statement is handled.

Visa and MastercardSupported lines are compared with the networks’ dated published schedules when the statement period, detail, and mapping support the check. The hosted application runs 2026.10ku-hosted.1, based on upstream 2026.10ku, with authorized pack 2026-10jz; the pack ID is a release artifact label, not a network schedule.
Discover and American ExpressDiscover is confirm-only against a state-republished Appendix G reference. Unmatched lines remain named and unpriced. The hosted application reports American Express amounts as billed. In the audit service, an OptBlue comparison may be made against a processor pricing guide when the statement identifies the pricing level and the supporting evidence is available.
How a statement is handledIn the hosted application, statement and Schedule A files are read in your browser and are not uploaded to the Statement Forensics backend. A statement sent in for the audit service is used only to produce the reports and is deleted when they are delivered.
Evidence limitsA finding is a discrepancy against a published rate; a screening flag needs more evidence; a term is a price that is negotiable, not wrong. Figures are floors where that is what the statement proves, a statement that does not reconcile is marked provisional, and anything the statement cannot show is stated, not estimated.

Built for the channel

The audit is the door-opener; the findings are the close; the risk brief is the retention.

The margin your ISO doesn’t share with you

Interchange billed above the published rate sits inside a line presented as pass-through — so it never appears as disclosed margin, and it is generally outside the residual you are paid on. That makes it the one check protecting your own economics as directly as your merchant’s. You cannot ask for a share of margin nobody has told you exists.

Win the statement, win the account

The full cost stack, reconciled to the penny, with the negotiable price isolated — the conversation starts from evidence, not a rate quote.

The risk brief: retention gold

Fraud patterns, network fines, and monitoring exposure — surfaced on a client-ready page. Findings the incumbent never mentioned are how accounts move.

Schedule A, and proposals at your buy rates

Load your Schedule A — common formats are read automatically, and manual entry always works — and price a proposal from the prospect’s own statement, over its own card-network cost. Average ticket, monthly volume and highest ticket come with it, for the new-account submission.

Your whole book in one run

On ISO and team plans, portfolio mode takes up to 25 statements from any merchants. Each merchant gets its own report, and one internal summary ranks the book by what each processor keeps above the card networks’ cost, with every merchant’s issues. Flat-rate accounts, whose statements hide that cost, are listed in their own section, ranked by effective rate.

Recoveries without a negotiation

Fallback-bucket transactions named with cause, fix, and dollars. Visa’s 2026 commercial-data overhaul makes this urgent — accounts still mapped to the retired Level 2 program are repriced above no-data rates. You deliver the fix; the merchant keeps the savings.

Protect the book you already have

Attrition rarely announces itself. Your merchants get repriced and nobody tells you — the notice lands in the fine print of their statement, not in your inbox. A gateway update or a new hire at the counter starts downgrading transactions. Dispute ratios drift toward a monitoring program. The merchant notices eventually — usually when a competitor shows them. A periodic statement review across your book means you find it first.

Repricing you weren’t told about

Processors reprice portfolios quietly — pre-announced in statement messages or landing with no notice at all. A periodic pass catches each change, prices it, and traces it to its announcement (or the absence of one).

Downgrades creep in

A configuration change, a processing habit, a program the networks rewrote — suddenly transactions fall into pricier buckets. Each recurring downgrade is named with its cause and the fix you get to deliver. The savings arrive with your name on them.

Risk builds quietly

Integrity fines accumulate per faulty authorization; dispute ratios rise toward monitoring thresholds. The risk brief flags both while they’re still fixable — before the program letter arrives and the relationship sours.

A quarterly pass across your merchants turns every finding into a touchpoint: you bring the problem and the fix, before a competitor brings just the problem. Send a current merchant’s recent statement exactly as you would a prospect’s.

Why you can trust what it says

Independent. Beech Edwards has no stake in any processor or platform — nobody upstream profits from the findings, so the report has no reason to flatter anyone. Held in strict confidence. Your statements are seen only by the person doing your audit, and deleted when your report is delivered. Accountable to the penny. Every report reconciles against your statement’s own printed totals before it says a word — and if it can’t, it tells you that instead. Evidence, not promises. No inflated savings claims: the report shows what’s fixed, what’s negotiable, and what’s avoidable — in dollars — and the decision stays yours.


Questions, answered

Is my statement shared with anyone?

No. Statements are seen only by the person doing your audit, used only to produce your reports, and deleted when the reports are delivered. Never shared, never sold.

How do I know the numbers are right?

Every report reconciles against your statement’s own printed totals — to the penny — before it says a word. If any figure can’t be reconciled, the report says so plainly rather than presenting an unverified number.

What do “fixed” and “negotiable” mean?

Fixed is the card networks’ wholesale cost — interchange and assessments, the same for every processor. Negotiable is everything the processor adds on top. The audit’s core job is sorting every dollar into those three groups — network cost, your processor’s price, and anything on its own contract such as an equipment lease, because only one of them is worth a conversation.

Does it check debit card fees?

Yes, network by network. Debit sales on Visa and Mastercard signature debit are checked against their published rates like any other line. Debit sales on a PIN network are checked too: Interlink and Maestro against Visa’s and Mastercard’s published PIN rates; STAR, Accel, Pulse, NYCE, SHAZAM, Jeanie, AFFN and Culiance against the highest rate each network can charge; and a card from a big bank against the federal cap. Itemized switch fees are compared with the highest each network charges, and the processor’s markup on debit sales is shown wherever the statement lets it be measured. More on the debit networks →

What is a downgrade?

A transaction billed in a pricier rate bucket than it could have earned — usually a setup issue, not a pricing issue. The report names each recurring downgrade, its likely cause, and the fix. It’s money a negotiation can’t reach, because the remedy is operational.

Will it tell me how much I could save?

It tells you what is negotiable, what is avoidable, and what each is worth per month and per year — in dollars, anchored to your own statement. No inflated savings promises; the decision, and the negotiation, stay yours.

How many statements should I send?

One is enough to start. Two or more unlock the month-over-month work: price increases caught as they land, pre-announced changes matched to their notices, and trends. Up to twelve go in one report, and they don’t have to be consecutive.

Does it work with flat-rate processors (Square, Stripe, QuickBooks-style)?

Yes — those statements carry reported rates rather than interchange detail, and the audit adapts: it verifies the effective rate and the fee lines rather than pretending detail exists.

Who is behind this?

Beech Edwards LLC — an independent consulting practice with 35+ years across banking risk, processing, acquiring, and payfac operations, and no processor affiliation.

Four things that decide whether an audit holds up
Measured against the published schedule — not a market average, and not only your contract. Visa and Mastercard publish their rates, and this audit compares supported lines with the applicable schedules at a named edition date. A tool that benchmarks you against other merchants tells you whether you are normal. If padding is widespread, normal is the wrong target. A tool that checks only your contract tells you whether they billed what they promised — it cannot tell you the promise was expensive.
Two paths, and they make different promises. In the audit tool, the statement and Schedule A are read in your browser and are not uploaded to the Statement Forensics backend; the hosted service supplies authentication, entitlement, watermark identity and the authorized rate vintage. A statement sent in for the audit service is used only to produce the reports and is deleted when they are delivered. No agreement has to be handed to a third party either way.
Every figure carries its evidence tier, and the limits are printed. A finding is a discrepancy against a published rate. A screening flag is a signal that needs more. A term is a price that is negotiable rather than wrong. They are never blended, figures are stated as floors where a floor is what the statement proves, and where something cannot be shown the report says so instead of estimating.
Nothing is sold downstream. Beech Edwards LLC has no processor, ISO or platform affiliation, takes no share of any recovery, and has nothing to switch you to. Most statement audits are offered by someone who wants the account. This one ends with the report.
And one thing nothing else does at all. The audit reads the repricing notice out of your statement’s own message text — the paragraph nobody reads — quotes it exactly, and flags the window you have to object. Then, given the next statement, it proves whether the increase actually landed and what it cost. Announced in one month, measured in the next, linked back to the notice by name.
None of the above is an opinion about anybody else’s product. They are questions — ask them of this one too, and ask them before you trust a single figure from any audit, including this one.

Ready when you are

Send one recent statement — or up to twelve — or ask to see a complete sample report first. Gary follows up personally.

Request an audit

For business owners. Email one to twelve recent statements to audit@statementforensics.com (PDF, scans and photos read too), or ask for the complete sample report first, worked from a sample merchant.

Email a statementAsk for the sample report

Tell us how to reach you and we will follow up about your statement review.

Request access or a walkthrough

For agents, ISOs, CPAs, bookkeepers and MSPs. Authorized access is available now; accounts are set up individually during launch, and Gary will set yours up or book a walkthrough.

Request access

Tell us how to reach you and Gary will set up your account or book a walkthrough.

Gary Rutledge · Managing Partner, Beech Edwards LLC · Gary@statementforensics.com · 402.670.3445 · www.statementforensics.com